Economics in Romance of the Seven Worlds

The key to understanding the economy in the Romance of the Seven Worlds megagame is to know that it is not a growth based economy. It tries to model a feudal system of power, not a capitalist system of power. The Emperor also has a highly developed sense of the aesthetic value of undeveloped wilderness, and polluting your home world with the toxic wastes of heavy industry is one of the ways the Emperor might be persuaded that your home world should be destroyed.

Income

No one in the game has a cash income that they get on a regular basis – even Imperial ministers have to compete for their budgets. This game’s equivalent of Resource Points (RPs) is the Radium Point – same RP abbreviation, sexy new glow in the dark colour. The vast majority of RPs available to the players are from mining on Targol (the imperial capital world). Anyone with a Rocket unit can fly to a region where the Control team spawn RPs, and if no one else wants to fight you for it, you collect the RPs. One region might have 50 RP, a second region 20 RPs, and a third region 5 RPs. Only the Noble and Guild players have Rockets at the start, so if the other players want RPs they will have to beg, borrow, or trade goods and services for them.

There is an opportunity cost to mining for RPs on Targol – if you only have one Rocket you cannot also use it to fight meteors in the same turn you are mining. Not defending your world is a bad thing.

It is quite possible that you will experience a cycle of good and bad income turns, where you fluctuate between plenty and starvation in terms of your ability to afford build actions. Its always good to have friends who can loan you a few RPs.

Economic Actions

Each of the three types of world role (Noble, Guild, Commons) has a different type of economic structure, called a Base, that has four different types of economic action available to them. Each Base is linked to a specific region on one of the maps ( a noble palace, guild hall, or common city). Lose control of that region and you lose most of your economic power. Below are three examples of Bases. Each action can normally be done twice a turn, but Widgets (a rare token) allow a third action to be done at the second action cost. The cost is in RPs – if the cost is 0, then it is a free action for you. Everyone should have at least one free action. If the cost is “T”, then the RP cost is equal to the game turn number.

Damage from meteors that hit worlds will increase the cost of actions, as can pollution, damage from combats, rebel sabotage, or pulp actions by other players.

Three examples follow – these are working drafts and not final.

Guild base example – a world that specialises in science.

Commons base example – a world that specialises in warfare.

Noble base example – a world that specialises in cognitive drugs useful in science and training.

Trade

Players can trade most game tokens – RPs, Widgets, Fuel, Zing, Science dice, and strength cubes. The different action costs mean that it may be cheaper for another player to do that action, and some players are more effective at some actions than others. The commons players, for example, are nearly always better at actions that influence world loyalty.

One of the functions of the economic system is to provide reasons for the players to talk with each other. Several key resources only exist on one world.

Terms, conditions, and enforcement of trade deals and loans is entirely in the hands of the players.

New Economic Bases

One possible outcome of an imperial petition in the Council phase is that the Emperor can grant permission to build a new economic base. Some science projects can also allow players to build new economic bases. If you can capture another player’s base, then you can use it – but of course before you can capture it in chivalric warfare, you need formal permission from an Imperial Minister. Some science projects might also change the cost or effectiveness of some economic actions.

Next blog post will probably be on the Science subgame.

The imaginary economy

The World Bank put out a report this week, a Knowledge Map of the Virtual Economy (http://www.infodev.org/en/Publication.1056.html) in which they try to estimate the value of various virtual services, including that for online gaming.  The information in there about the real cash for fake gold market is interesting, although as it is dealing with a grey market, all the figures should be taken with a grain of salt.  The highlights that stood out to me:

• most gold farmers make minimum wage
• the middlemen, with english language skills and a university education, make more
• around 20-25 percent of players buy gold
• people buying gold spend an average of US$369 a year
• it costs US$6-8 to for each click on a google advert for “wow gold”
• the total market is estimated to be US$3 billion in 2009.

Currently on my World of Warcraft server, the gold farmers are offering to sell 10,000 gold for a bit over US$21.

It has been interesting watching the economy inflate in World of Warcraft over the last few months.  A key factor in this has been “the obsidium shuffle”, which has essentially given people with Jewellcrafter (JC) professions a license to mint gold.  The shuffle works because when a JC prospects a stack of ore, they get 6 low quality gems and a chance of a high quality gem.  The low quality gems sell for 9 gold each to a vendor, even though they are useless to player characters, the rare gems will sell for between 4 and 100 gold on my server.  So if you can buy a stack of ore for under 54 gold, and you have the time to right-click with your mouse 16-20 times, instant profit.  Each of the other stacks of ore have similar “floor” price points, under which you cannot lose gold on buying them.

On some servers, because of bot programmes run by “gold farmers” the price of a stack of Obsidium has dropped to around 6 gold per stack.  On my server, I can usually pick it up for 45-46 gold per stack.  So not as profitable, but still faster than doing any kind of in-game Player versus Environment content.  In an upcoming patch, the vendor value of the low quality gems is being reduced from 9 gold to 75 silver (100 silver to the gold), so the floor price will drop considerably.  I expect the Auction House (AH) price to follow it down as well.  The new equilibrium will still probably allow money to be made from the shuffle, just not in such excessive amounts.

The cat is out of the bag already though.  Large numbers of players in the game have already made large profits, and there is not a lot to actually spend it on.  Just before the Cataclysm expansion was released the in-game old cap per character was increased from 214,000 to 1,000,000.  In the five months since then I have increased my AH traders gold pile from 214,000 to 640,000 (I probably have just over 700,000 across all my characters).  It costs me about 1,000 gold a week to raid, so that is enough in-game currency to play for 12+ years without having to run another quest in game for gold rewards.  So it means my game account would be worth about US$1,500 to a hacker in the gold farming/stealing business.

There are times when I wonder, if Blizzard introduced a purchasable title of “Merchant Prince”, for say 500,000 gold, just how many characters I would see in Orgrimmar the next day with it floating above their heads.

One area where you can see the impact of the inflation is the price being paid for cutting edge “bind on equip” Epic quality gear that characters can equip for raids.  Early in Wrath of the Lich King I recall spending a few thousand gold purchasing several Epic items for a new Level 80 character.  In Cataclysm, purchasing a similar set of  items for a new Level 85 character would cost me around 30,000 gold, and if I was playing a tank character closer to 50,000g.  Its just as well for me then, that there was actually nothing I could buy off the AH for my Paladin Healer that I could not craft for myself at cost price – buying off the AH would have got it for me faster, but not cheaper.

The other area you can see this is in the service economy, where people work for tips.  During Wrath of the Lich King, the default price to acquire signatories in-game for a Guild Charter (10 signs required to register a guild) was around 10 gold.  Sometimes it went up to 15 gold.  I now see people promising 50, even 100 gold for the same service.  For crafting services, I was often paid 10g for simple things in Wrath, and 50-100g if I had a rare pattern that was not universally obtainable.  In Cataclysm, I would not bother crafting an item for someone for less than a 500 gold tip, as I can usually make at least that, and sometimes as much as 1000g simply selling the item via the AH.

Blizzard recently announced a “Call to Arms”.

In patch 4.1 we’ll be introducing Dungeon Finder: Call to Arms, a new system intended to lower queue times. Call to Arms will automatically detect which class role is currently the least represented in the queue, and offer them additional rewards for entering the Dungeon Finder queue and completing a random level-85 Heroic dungeon.

Any time the Dungeon Finder queue is longer than a few minutes for level-85 Heroics, the Call to Arms system kicks in and determines which role is the least represented. In the case of tanking being the least represented role, the “Call to Arms: Tanks” icon will display in the Dungeon Finder UI menu where class roles are selected, and will also display on the UI when the queue pops and you are selected to enter a dungeon. Regardless of your role, you’ll always be able to see which role currently has been Called to Arms, if any.

Call to Arms is meant to lower wait times by offering additional rewards for queuing as the currently least represented role. To be eligible for the additional rewards you must solo queue for a random level-85 Heroic in the role that is currently being Called to Arms, and complete the dungeon by killing the final boss. Every time you hit these requirements (there is no daily limit) you’ll receive a goodie bag that will contain some gold, a chance at a rare gem, a chance at a flask/elixir (determined by spec), a good chance of receiving a non-combat pet (including cross faction pets), and a very rare chance at receiving a mount. The pets offered come from a wide variety of sources, and include companions like the Razzashi Hatchling, Cockatiel, and Tiny Sporebat, but the mounts are those specifically only available through dungeons (not raids), like the Reins of the Raven Lord from Sethekk Halls, Swift White Hawkstrider from Magister’s Terrace, and Deathcharger’s Reins from Stratholme.

This system is meant to address the unacceptable queue times currently being experienced by those that queue for the DPS role at max level. The long queue times are, of course, caused by a very simple lack of representation in the Dungeon Finder by tanks, and to some extent healers. We don’t feel the tanking and healing roles have any inherent issues that are causing the representation disparity, except that fulfilling them carries more responsibility. Understandably, players prefer to take on that responsibility in more organized situations than what the Dungeon Finder offers, but perhaps we can bribe them a little. While this system gives tanks and healers something extra, the incentive is being provided so that we can help players in the DPS role get into more dungeons, get better gear, and continue progressing.

While the gold, gems, flasks, and elixirs are OK incentives, we knew we needed something more substantial. We had briefly considered Valor Points and epics, but decided that wouldn’t be working toward the goal of helping DPS players progress, and ultimately wouldn’t keep tanks and healers in the Dungeon Finder system for very long. We settled on pets and dungeon-found mounts as they’re cosmetic/achievement items that players tend to try to get on their own, so why not change that up and offer them a chance to get some of those elusive pets and mounts in a way that also helps other players? Even if they don’t get a pet or mount, or get one they already have, the gold and other goodies still feel rewarding enough that it won’t feel like a waste of effort.

We think it’s a pretty solid incentive to get tanks and healers queuing, give max-level players another way to collect the pets and mounts they so desire, and above all, to improve wait times for DPS players sitting in queues. In the case of lower level dungeons, it’s actually not uncommon for DPS to be the least represented role, and so if this new system works out and we’re pleased with the results, we may consider applying this same mechanic to lower level dungeons as well.

One thing that I think most of the other blogs discussing this missed, is that Blizzard is only doing in-game, what the players are already doing in-game.  Every day I see pure DPS characters advertising in the trade channels to group with a tank or healer to reduce their wait times, and where a few weeks ago 50-100 gold was being offered, now its 100-200 gold.  Once the Call to Arms feature is activated, these players are probably going to have to double their private payment to match the bribe from Blizzard.

Lesson for anyone rolling a new character in a new MMO: pick a tank or healer role as your primary role in the game, or begin to develop the patience of a saint.